Those who call themselves apostles: Revelation 2:2 and the duty to test leaders

In Revelation 2:2, Jesus commends the church at Ephesus for testing those who called themselves apostles. In Part 4 of our Four12 investigation, we examine why apostolic claims must be tested against Scripture and ask who holds translocal authority accountable.

Share
A church lectern behind glass, with the Four12 logo in the upper left.
Editorial illustration for the Four12 investigation. The logo identifies the subject of the article.
Andrew Selley holding a microphone while speaking at a Four12 event.
Andrew Selley founded Four12 Global and serves as its apostolic leader. Image source: Four12 Global, “The Timing & Process of God”.

Part 4 of the Four12 Apostolic Authority Investigation

Four12 Global logo
Four12 Global Apostolic Church Network

Jesus Commended a Church for Testing Apostles

One of the most overlooked passages in discussions about modern apostleship appears in Revelation 2:2.

Jesus says to the church at Ephesus:

“I know your works, your toil and your patient endurance, and how you cannot bear with those who are evil, but have tested those who call themselves apostles and are not, and found them to be false.”

That statement deserves careful attention.

Jesus does not condemn the Ephesians for questioning people who claimed apostolic authority.

He commends them.

They tested the claim.

They discovered that some who called themselves apostles were not apostles.

This establishes an important principle:

Apostolic claims are testable.


The Phrase “Those Who Call Themselves Apostles”

The wording is significant.

Jesus does not say:

“Those whom your leaders have declared to be apostles.”

He describes people who call themselves apostles.

The early Church therefore faced a problem that sounds surprisingly modern:

People claiming spiritual authority that others believed was not genuine.

That means the existence of a title is not proof of the office.

A person can be called something without actually being what he claims to be.


Authority Does Not Eliminate Testing

This principle runs throughout the New Testament.

Believers are told to:

  • test spiritual claims;
  • examine teaching;
  • beware of false prophets;
  • reject false gospels;
  • test those who claim spiritual authority;
  • and hold leaders accountable to God's Word.

The Church is never instructed to surrender discernment simply because someone carries an impressive title.

In fact, the greater the claimed authority, the more important discernment becomes.


Four12's Position on Accountability

This point deserves fairness.

Four12 itself teaches accountability.

Its material on recognizing and ordaining apostles discusses accountability to Scripture, other leaders, teams and mutual submission. Four12 explicitly says that apostolic leaders should not operate as isolated “rogue” authorities and emphasizes testing leaders according to Scripture.

Four12 also teaches that apostles and elders should operate through mutual submission rather than domination.

Those principles are not the problem.

They are commendable.

The question is whether the proposed accountability structure is sufficient to deal with the enormous authority associated with the apostolic office.


Who Tests the Testers?

This is where the issue becomes more difficult.

Suppose a movement recognizes an individual as an apostle.

Who has the authority to determine that the recognition was wrong?

Suppose that apostle becomes doctrinally unsound.

Who has authority to correct him?

Suppose the apostle refuses correction.

Who can remove him?

Suppose an apostle exercises inappropriate authority over churches.

Who can say:

“You have exceeded your biblical authority.”

Those questions are not theoretical.

They are exactly the questions raised by the existence of an office carrying translocal authority.


Recognition Is Not the Same as Divine Appointment

Four12 describes a process for recognizing and ordaining apostles involving leadership, team witness, character, track record and spiritual discernment.

But recognition raises a theological distinction.

A church can recognize what God has already done.

That does not necessarily mean the church has authority to create an office that Scripture itself does not establish.

For example, the early Church did not create the apostleship of Paul by voting him into office.

Paul explicitly said his apostleship was:

“not from men nor through man.”

— Galatians 1:1

That does not mean churches have no role in recognizing ministry.

It means recognition and divine commissioning are not identical concepts.


The Ephesus Test

The Ephesian church provides a model of discernment.

They did not simply ask:

“Does this person have a strong ministry?”

They asked:

“Is this claim true?”

That distinction matters enormously.

A person can demonstrate:

  • leadership ability;
  • courage;
  • charisma;
  • theological knowledge;
  • church growth;
  • organizational skill;
  • international influence;

and still be wrong about his claimed office.

The issue is truth.


Scripture Is the Standard

Four12's own accountability material says leaders, including apostles, should be tested according to Scripture.

That is precisely the right starting point.

But it produces a further question.

What does Scripture say an apostle is?

If Scripture defines apostleship in one way and a modern movement defines it differently, saying “we test ourselves by Scripture” is not enough.

The definition itself must be tested.


The Problem of Circular Accountability

There is a potential problem with internally controlled accountability systems.

Consider this hypothetical structure:

  1. Apostolic leaders recognize apostles.
  2. Those apostles help govern the network.
  3. The network recognizes their authority.
  4. The same network provides accountability.
  5. The network determines whether the accountability process has been satisfied.

This can be healthy if genuine mutual submission exists.

But it can also become circular.

The question becomes:

Who stands outside the circle with sufficient authority to say that the entire structure is wrong?

Revelation 2 suggests that churches must retain the ability to reject false claims.


Paul Was Willing to Be Examined

Paul's own ministry provides a fascinating example.

He defended his apostleship vigorously.

But he did not teach Christians that his authority made examination unnecessary.

Instead, his letters contain repeated appeals to truth, evidence, doctrine, conduct and fruit.

He even confronted Peter publicly when Peter's conduct compromised the gospel.

That is significant.

If an apostle could be confronted by another apostle, then apostolic authority was not equivalent to personal infallibility.


Apostolic Authority Is Not Absolute Authority

The New Testament recognizes authority.

But Christian authority is always subordinate to Christ.

Paul could say:

“Be imitators of me, as I am of Christ.”

The qualification matters.

The ultimate standard was not Paul.

It was Christ.

Christian leaders possess delegated authority.

They do not become the source of truth.

That distinction becomes increasingly important as the claimed level of authority rises.


What Happens When an Apostle Is Wrong?

This is perhaps the most practical question in the investigation.

Suppose a modern apostle teaches something demonstrably contrary to Scripture.

What happens?

If the answer is:

“He can be corrected by his peers,”

then we should ask what happens if his peers agree with him.

If the answer is:

“The local elders can challenge him,”

then we should ask whether those elders actually possess authority to reject his apostolic direction.

If the answer is:

“The wider network can intervene,”

then we should ask who governs the wider network.

If the answer ultimately becomes:

“God will deal with him,”

then the accountability structure may not be sufficient.


The New Testament Does Not Fear Testing

This is important because accountability is sometimes portrayed as divisive.

But biblical testing is not inherently divisive.

It protects the Church.

The Bereans examined Paul's teaching.

The Ephesians tested those claiming apostleship.

Christians were told to test the spirits.

Paul instructed churches to examine prophetic speech.

The New Testament expects Christians to exercise discernment.


A Healthy Church Should Be Able to Say “No”

Any genuine system of spiritual authority must allow the Church to say:

“No.”

No to false teaching.

No to manipulation.

No to unbiblical authority.

No to spiritual intimidation.

No to claims that cannot be demonstrated from Scripture.

No to leaders who place themselves beyond correction.

The ability to say “no” is not rebellion.

Sometimes it is obedience.


The Question for Four12

Four12 deserves to be evaluated by its own stated standard.

It says accountability matters.

It says apostles are accountable to Scripture.

It says mutual submission matters.

It says apostles should not lord authority over churches.

Those principles are biblical.

The remaining question is:

Does the Four12 model provide a sufficiently biblical mechanism for testing and correcting the apostolic office it recognizes?

And even before that:

Has Scripture established that such an office should exist today?

That is the question we cannot bypass.


Testing the Claim

Revelation 2:2 leaves us with a principle that should govern every generation:

**Do not merely test the person.

Test the claim.**

Do not merely ask whether the leader is sincere.

Ask whether the office is biblical.

Do not merely ask whether the ministry produces results.

Ask whether the ministry conforms to Scripture.

Do not merely ask whether the person has been recognized.

Ask whether the recognition corresponds to the biblical pattern.


The Question We Take Into Part 5

There is another issue that frequently appears when allegations of leadership failure arise:

repentance.

Repentance is absolutely central to Christianity.

But repentance can never mean:

“An accusation has been answered simply because someone says they have repented.”

Four12 itself teaches that genuine repentance involves more than feeling bad. Its published teaching describes repentance as involving genuine change, confession and appropriate action.

So the question becomes:

What does biblical repentance actually require when serious accusations are made against Christian leaders?

That is the subject of Part 5.

**Repentance is essential.

But repentance must never become a substitute for truth, accountability and justice.


Part 5 — Repentance Is Not a Get-Out-of-Accountability Card

Start with Part 1: The Foundation Has Been Laid


Follow the investigation

Get new NAR Trojan Horse investigations in your inbox. I examine the teachings, claims, and networks shaping the church and test them against Scripture.

If this work helps you, consider supporting the time it takes to trace claims back to their sources and publish these investigations.

Support the research