Did the Apostles Really Have Successors? Andrew Selley, Four12 Global, and the Evidence of Church History
Andrew Selley argues that church history supports continuing apostles. But do Clement, Polycarp, Ignatius, the Didache and John Calvin establish the kind of apostolic government taught by Four12 Global?


Four12 Global argues that modern apostles are necessary for healthy church government. But do the early Church Fathers and Protestant Reformers actually support that conclusion?
Andrew Selley, the leading figure associated with Four12 Global, has made an important historical argument in a recorded conversation titled Were There Apostles After the Twelve?
He appeals to Clement of Rome, Polycarp, Ignatius, the Didache, John Calvin and Martin Luther to argue that apostolic ministry continued after the original apostles.
Some of his historical quotations are correct.
That is precisely why the argument deserves serious examination.
The question is not simply whether Christians continued to use the word apostle after the New Testament period. Nor is it whether gifted missionaries, church planters and reformers continued to serve Christ's church.
The decisive question is this:
Did the early church recognize a continuing, distinct office of translocal apostles who possessed governing authority over local churches and the appointment of their elders?
That is the claim we must test.
What Four12 actually teaches about apostles
In a separate Four12 recording, Who Appoints Elders?, Selley appeals to Acts 14:23 and Titus 1:5 to argue that elder appointments originate outside the local congregation, through apostolic ministry.
He explicitly distinguishes this from congregational voting or appointment by a local pastor acting independently.
In Were There Apostles After the Twelve?, he develops the wider argument. Local eldership, even in plurality, is presented as insufficient without apostolic and other translocal ministries.
Yet Selley also makes two qualifications that should not be overlooked.
He says modern apostles do not write Scripture, and he says apostolic authority must be recognized rather than demanded. He even acknowledges that local elders may reject someone they judge to be a false apostle.
These qualifications matter. Our disagreement concerns the biblical necessity and governmental authority of the office Four12 proposes—not an allegation that every association with Four12 is involuntary.
1. Clement of Rome: Was he called an apostle?
Selley cites Clement of Alexandria's Stromata, Book IV, chapter 17, which refers to Clement of Rome as an apostle.
The quotation is genuine.
This is evidence that the term apostle could be applied to a Christian leader outside the familiar list of the Twelve and Paul.
But the existence of a title does not settle the nature of the office.
Clement of Rome's own letter to the Corinthians, especially chapters 42–44, discusses the appointment and succession of bishops or presbyters and deacons.
His concern is the faithful preservation of established church leadership and the wrongful removal of blameless ministers.
What the passage does not explicitly establish is a separate, permanently continuing class of translocal apostles governing those ministers.
The distinction is between apostolic succession in teaching and ordained ministry and succession to a particular apostolic governing office.
They are not automatically identical.
Primary sources: Clement of Alexandria, Stromata IV.17; 1 Clement 42–44.
2. Polycarp: An apostolic teacher—or an apostle?
Selley next appeals to the Martyrdom of Polycarp, chapter 16, which describes Polycarp as an apostolic and prophetic teacher.
Again, the description is genuine.
But notice the terminology.
Polycarp is described as a teacher characterized as apostolic and prophetic. This is not the same as an unambiguous statement that he held a distinct office of apostle.
Jerome later describes Polycarp as bishop of Smyrna and a leading figure throughout Asia.
That is significant historical testimony to Polycarp's standing and influence.
It does not, however, provide a constitutional account of Polycarp exercising binding apostolic jurisdiction over all Asian churches.
Indeed, Jerome identifies him as a bishop.
The historical evidence demonstrates an influential leader who preserved and transmitted apostolic Christianity. It does not, by itself, demonstrate the governmental office Four12 wishes to recover.
Primary sources: Martyrdom of Polycarp 16.2; Jerome, On Illustrious Men 17.
3. Ignatius: The bishop who distinguished himself from the apostles
Ignatius of Antioch is another central figure in Selley's argument.
Ignatius wrote to several churches, warned against false teaching and strongly emphasized church order.
Those activities certainly resemble some functions performed by New Testament apostles.
But resemblance of function is not identity of office.
In his Letter to the Romans, chapter 4, Ignatius explicitly distinguishes himself from Peter and Paul, acknowledging their status as apostles.
His other letters strongly advocate the authority of bishops, presbyters and deacons.
This creates a difficulty for Selley's historical reconstruction.
If Ignatius regarded himself as a bishop rather than an apostle, his correspondence cannot simply be treated as proof that he possessed a continuing apostolic office under another name.
It may demonstrate the development of episcopal authority. Whether that development was entirely desirable is a separate theological question.
Primary sources: Ignatius, Romans 4; Smyrnaeans 8.
4. The Didache: Perhaps the most important evidence of all
The Didache is an early Christian instruction manual.
In chapter 11, it gives directions for receiving and testing traveling apostles and prophets.
Selley correctly recognizes the importance of this passage.
The early Christian communities addressed by the document evidently knew of people who traveled under those designations.
But chapter 15 introduces a critical qualification.
It instructs the community to appoint bishops and deacons for itself.
This is remarkable because both instructions occur in the same document.
The Didache recognizes itinerant apostles while also addressing local communities as responsible for appointing their own officers.
Selley interprets the latter instruction as evidence of an emerging departure from the proper apostolic pattern.
But that is an interpretation he brings to the document.
The Didache itself does not condemn the instruction as a dangerous innovation. It presents the appointment of worthy local officers as part of the community's responsibilities.
This does not prove that the earliest churches practiced modern congregational elections. The text does not prescribe a particular ballot procedure.
But it does challenge the categorical claim that legitimate appointments must always originate from an external apostolic authority.
Nor should the document's uncertain date be ignored. Its references to traveling apostles do not, without further argument, prove that those ministries continued after the death of every original apostle.
Primary source: Didache 11 and 15.
5. Timothy and Titus: What did Eusebius actually say?
Selley cites Eusebius's Ecclesiastical History, Book III, chapter 4, concerning Timothy and Titus.
The passage is genuine.
Eusebius records Timothy as receiving episcopal oversight at Ephesus and Titus as associated with oversight of churches in Crete.
But Eusebius is writing historical tradition using the language of episcopal office.
He does not explicitly say that Timothy and Titus founded an indefinitely continuing class of apostles who must govern local elderships in every generation.
Acts 14:23 and Titus 1:5 undoubtedly show that Paul, Barnabas and Paul's delegates participated in appointing elders.
The question is whether those particular apostolic commissions establish a universal, perpetual requirement for external apostolic appointment.
That conclusion requires more than observing what the original apostles and their delegates did.
Primary sources: Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History III.4.6; Acts 14:23; Titus 1:5.
6. John Calvin really did call Martin Luther an apostle
This is another point on which Selley deserves a clear acknowledgment.
Calvin did describe Luther as a distinguished apostle of Christ in his 1543 response to Albert Pighius.
The quotation is authentic.
But Calvin's meaning must be tested against Calvin's own explanation of church offices.
In Institutes of the Christian Religion, IV.3.4, Calvin allows that God may exceptionally raise up apostolic or evangelistic ministers when the church needs extraordinary reform.
In the same discussion, he explicitly denies that those extraordinary offices were established as perpetual, ordinary offices in the church.
For Calvin, recognizing Luther's extraordinary reforming ministry was not equivalent to requiring every local church to submit to an ongoing apostolic field.
An exceptional use of the word apostle is not proof of a permanent apostolic government.
Primary sources: Calvin, Defence Against Pighius (1543); Institutes IV.3.4.
7. The biblical question remains unanswered
Four12's historical evidence demonstrates several important realities.
Christians continued to honor apostolic teaching. Churches had recognized leaders. Missionaries and teachers traveled between congregations. Influential bishops exercised authority and offered correction. Exceptional reformers were sometimes described in apostolic language.
None of those facts is seriously in dispute.
But they do not establish the specific conclusion Four12 needs.
Where does Scripture require every local congregation to remain under a contemporary translocal apostle?
Where does Scripture establish that the office responsible for appointing elders must continue indefinitely after the foundational apostolic generation?
And where do the earliest Christian sources clearly identify that continuing office as distinct from bishops, presbyters and ordinary missionary ministry?
Ephesians 2:20 describes the apostles and prophets in connection with the church's foundation.
Ephesians 4:11–16 describes Christ's gifts for the church's maturity.
The existence of an ongoing need for maturity does not, by itself, settle whether every ministry mentioned in Ephesians 4 continues in precisely the same office, authority and form.
Likewise, the historical appointment of elders by Paul and Barnabas does not automatically establish an exclusive appointment procedure for all subsequent centuries.
These are arguments that must be demonstrated, not merely assumed.
Conclusion: The difference between apostolic ministry and apostolic government
Andrew Selley's historical argument should not be dismissed as though every quotation were invented.
Several of his citations are accurate. Some provide meaningful evidence for broader uses of apostolic language in Christian history.
But the crucial distinction remains.
Evidence that apostolic teaching, missionary work and church leadership continued is not proof that the governing office of apostle continued in the form claimed by Four12 Global.
The Didache is particularly difficult for a universal external-appointment rule because it recognizes traveling apostles while instructing local communities to appoint their own officers.
Calvin is equally difficult for an argument about perpetual apostolic government because he explicitly distinguishes exceptional apostolic-type ministry from ordinary, permanent church offices.
The church certainly needs biblical doctrine, faithful elders, mutual accountability and protection against false teachers.
The question is whether Christ has made submission to contemporary translocal apostles the indispensable safeguard of those things.
On the historical evidence examined here, that claim remains unproven.
And the burden of proof belongs to those who insist that such an office is necessary for the church today.
Primary sources and further reading
- Four12 Global, Were There Apostles After the Twelve? — Andrew Selley and Steve Martinez.
- Four12 Global, Who Appoints Elders? — Andrew Selley and Adam Hellyer.
- Clement of Alexandria, Stromata, IV.17.
- First Epistle of Clement, chapters 42–44.
- Martyrdom of Polycarp, chapter 16.
- Ignatius, Letter to the Romans, chapter 4.
- Didache, chapters 11 and 15.
- Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, III.4.
- Jerome, On Illustrious Men, chapter 17.
- John Calvin, Defence Against Pighius (1543).
- John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, IV.3.4.
Start with Part 1: The Foundation Has Been Laid
For related reading, see the distinction between biblical eldership and apostolic alignment.
Follow the investigation
Get new NAR Trojan Horse investigations in your inbox. I examine the teachings, claims, and networks shaping the church and test them against Scripture.
If this work helps you, consider supporting the time it takes to trace claims back to their sources and publish these investigations.