Faith, Formula, or Fiction? What Christianity in Crisis Exposes About the Prosperity Gospel

Is faith an impersonal force or trust in a Creator? Using the F-L-A-W-S framework from Christianity in Crisis, this post contrasts "positive confession," the "little gods" teaching, and the prosperity gospel against the historical context of Scripture.

Share
A brass calculator and a closed Bible sit on a cobalt desk under a lamp.
Editorial illustration for the review of Christianity in Crisis.

For decades, modern Christian media has echoed a compelling message: Your words create your reality. God is obligated to heal your diseases. Sowing a financial seed guarantees a hundredfold return.

These ideas sound empowering. They pack arenas, build media networks, and promise believers absolute mastery over their health, bank accounts, and futures.

Yet underneath the polished presentations and familiar biblical vocabulary lies a fundamental theological shift. In his landmark work Christianity in Crisis, author and apologist Hank Hanegraaff delivered a rigorous, verse-by-verse examination of the Word of Faith movement and the Prosperity Gospel, arguing that the movement does not merely introduce peripheral eccentricities—it distorts historic Christian orthodoxy at its roots.

To diagnose how this theology veers off-course, Hanegraaff structured his critique around an unforgettable acronym: F-L-A-W-S. Here is what those five pillars teach, how they contrast with Scripture, and why sound biblical discernment matters today more than ever.

1. Faith Force (F): Impersonal Power vs. Living Trust

In historic Christian theology, faith is an attitude of humble, relational trust in a personal, sovereign God. The efficacy of faith rests entirely on the trustworthiness and power of its object: the Lord Himself.
In Word of Faith theology, faith undergoes a radical redefinition:

  • The Error: Faith is described as a metaphysical, impersonal force governed by immutable spiritual laws. Proponents teach that God used this "faith force" to create the universe, and that humans activate it through vocalization—a doctrine commonly known as Positive Confession. Words are viewed as physical containers of creative energy capable of bending reality.
  • The Scriptural Correction: Scripture affirms that God alone creates ex nihilo (out of nothing) by His sovereign decree (Psalm 33:6–9; Romans 4:17). Passages like Proverbs 18:21 ("Death and life are in the power of the tongue") are Hebrew wisdom literature addressing the practical, moral consequences of honest speech versus slander—not manual instructions for verbal incantations. In the original Greek of Mark 11:22, Jesus' command to "Have faith in God" denotes an objective trust in a sovereign Creator, not operating an independent spiritual mechanism.

2. Little Gods (L): Deification vs. Redeemed Humanity

Perhaps the most startling concept in Word of Faith theology is the claim regarding human nature.

  • The Error: Leaders within the movement argue that because Adam was created in the image of God, he was designed as an exact duplicate of God in kind. Following the new birth, believers are told they are restored to divine status—often summarized in phrases like "dogs produce dogs, cats produce cats, and God produces gods."
  • The Scriptural Correction: From Genesis to Revelation, the Bible maintains an uncompromised ontological divide between the infinite, uncreated Creator and finite, created human beings. In Isaiah 43:10, God states unequivocally: "Before Me no god was formed, nor shall there be any after Me." Humans are redeemed creatures and adopted children of God, but we never attain deity. The idea that humanity can cross into divinity is not Christian doctrine; it is the original deception whispered in the garden in Genesis 3:5: "You will be like God."

3. Atonement Atrocities (A): Paid on the Cross vs. "Born Again in Hell"

To sustain the notion that humans must be restored to godhood, the movement had to reconstruct what happened on the cross. This has produced what theologians label the JDS ("Jesus Died Spiritually") or "Born-Again Jesus" doctrine.

  • The Error: Prominent Faith teachers argue that Christ's physical death and shed blood on the cross were insufficient to purchase human redemption. Instead, they teach that Jesus took on the spiritual nature of Satan, died spiritually, was dragged into hell to be tortured by demons for three days, and had to be "born again" in the underworld before His bodily resurrection.
  • The Scriptural Correction: When Jesus hung on the cross, His final proclamation was "Tetelestai"—"It is finished" (John 19:30). In the ancient world, this was an accounting term stamped across bills to signify a debt paid in full. Colossians 1:20 explicitly declares that God made peace through "the blood of His cross." Hebrews 10:10 confirms that believers are sanctified through "the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all." Christ never took on the satanic nature, was never spiritually corrupt, and never needed redemption.

4. Wealth and Want (W): Stewardship vs. Spiritual Extortion

The Prosperity Gospel presents material wealth as an absolute covenant entitlement.

  • The Error: Financial poverty is viewed as a curse or an indicator of deficient faith. Ministers frequently use "seed-faith" appeals, telling congregants that financial giving to a particular ministry guarantees a contractual, "hundredfold" cash return from God.
  • The Scriptural Correction: When Jesus delivered the Parable of the Sower, He explicitly stated what the seed represents: "The sower sows the word" (Mark 4:14). The harvest is spiritual fruit and eternal life, not sports cars and private jets. When Jesus mentions a hundredfold in Mark 10:29–30, He explicitly includes "with persecutions." In 1 Timothy 6:9–10, the Apostle Paul warns that "those who desire to be rich fall into temptation, into a snare... For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil." Biblical giving is a joyful, sacrificial response to grace—never an investment strategy to manipulate God into a payout.

5. Sickness and Suffering (S): Bodily Hope vs. Cruel Condemnation

The final pillar of the system directly affects people in their most vulnerable moments: physical illness.

  • The Error: Teachers assert that physical health was purchased in the Atonement in such a way that every believer has a legal right to immediate, total healing in this life. If an illness persists, the burden is placed entirely on the sufferer: they are accused of lacking faith, harboring secret sin, or speaking "negative confessions."
  • The Scriptural Correction: When 1 Peter 2:24 quotes Isaiah 53:5 ("by His stripes you were healed"), Peter places the healing in the realm of spiritual reconciliation: Christ bore our sins so that we might die to sin and live to righteousness. While God can and does heal physical ailments in accordance with His sovereign will, complete bodily redemption belongs to the resurrection at Christ's return (Romans 8:22–23; 1 Corinthians 15:51–54). Godly men throughout Scripture—including Job, the Apostle Paul with his "thorn in the flesh" (2 Corinthians 12:7–10), and Timothy with his frequent ailments (1 Timothy 5:23)—faced bodily affliction without any condemnation of weak faith. Blaming the sick for their symptoms adds unbiblical guilt to physical suffering.

Where Did This Come From? The Historical Lineage

Hank Hanegraaff demonstrates that these doctrines did not emerge from standard biblical exegesis. Instead, their historical roots trace back to the 19th-century New Thought movement led by Phineas Quimby—a metaphysical philosophy asserting that the physical world is governed by mental and verbal states.

These ideas were integrated into Christian terminology by E. W. Kenyon in the early 20th century, and later popularized in charismatic circles by Kenneth E. Hagin and his disciples. By dressing metaphysical mental science in biblical language, ancient mind-over-matter philosophy was reintroduced to the church under the banner of "faith."

Reclaiming True Biblical Faith

DimensionWord of Faith MovementHistoric Biblical Christianity
Object of FaithOften "faith in faith" or spoken wordsGod alone, resting in His sovereign character
View of Humanity"Little gods" possessing divine creative powerRedeemed creatures, adopted children of God
The AtonementCompleted in hell through spiritual regenerationCompleted on the cross by Christ's physical sacrifice
Prayer PostureCommanding outcomes and demanding rightsSubmitting humbly: "Not my will, but Yours be done"
Suffering & TrialsProof of doubt, sin, or negative confessionExpected trials in a fallen world that refine character

Letting go of the prosperity gospel does not mean abandoning bold faith; it means trading an exhausting system of self-reliance for the real Jesus. It means stepping off the treadmill of having to speak reality into existence, and resting in the grace of a sovereign, loving Heavenly Father who works all things together for the good of those who love Him.

For related reading, see how Word of Faith teachers explain Jesus’ death and atonement.


Follow the investigation

Get new NAR Trojan Horse investigations in your inbox. I examine the teachings, claims, and networks shaping the church and test them against Scripture.

If this work helps you, consider supporting the time it takes to trace claims back to their sources and publish these investigations.

Support the research